Skip to Content

An Algorithm May Decide If You Can Be Out on Bail ~ the End of California’s Cash Bail System

Credit: Pro Liberate.

[dropcap size=big]C[/dropcap]alifornia judges and math — not how much bail you can afford — will now make the ultimate decision as to whether a defendant must remain in custody prior to trial. The state last month became the first in the nation to eliminate the cash bail system, striking a death-knell blow to a $2 billion industry.

The new bill, which goes into effect in October of next year, would put the onus on judges or a mathematical algorithm to decide who gets released and any supervision stipulations. Under California’s current law, defendants buy their bail through a bondsman or put up cash. Often this means wealthier people can afford to post bail and poor people must either borrow or put up collateral in order to avoid sitting in a cell while awaiting trial.

Bail is currently set according to a schedule, which corresponds to the charge and the defendant’s history. The new law would replace this with an algorithm being called “Pretrial Assessment Services” that decides a defendant's risk level.

Those shown to be low to medium risk would be sent home without even seeing a judge, with some supervision conditions. Meanwhile, those deemed a high-risk are detained until a bail hearing. The judge considers the offender's rap sheet and history of adhering to court appearances.

Relief statues adorn one entrance of the L.A. Superior Courthouse/Image by Joe Wolf, via Flickr.

[dropcap size=big]S[/dropcap]upporters of the new law believe that it combats racial and economic discrimination, and makes the pre-trial period smoother.

Nonetheless, critics — including the ACLU — say the law simply replaces the old system with another unequal system, where powerful judges can use it as a tool to detain people for prolonged periods in cases where a trial might not result in conviction or harsh enough sentencing. They also say the algorithm is an inhumane way of assessing a person’s criminal liability.  

In an L.A. Times op-ed, human rights advocates John Raphling and Pete White gave a powerful argument:

“The risk assessment tools purport to estimate the likelihood of a person getting re-arrested, or missing a court date. They draw on facts about that person — without considering context — to create a profile. Exactly what facts the tools take into account isn’t defined in the new law, but presumably they will include arrest records. The tools produce a score based on the past behavior of others with matching profiles.”

There are also concerns that some of the same issues with the retiring bail system will transfer to the new one. Detained defendants may feel pressure to just plead guilty because of financial reasons, or to avoid the long wait for a trail.

RELATED: Major Shift on Police: Cops Will Have to Release Body Camera Footage and Records on Bad Behavior

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from L.A. TACO

Protester Whose Testicle Exploded After LAPD Officer Shot Him with ‘Less Lethal’ Firearm Receives $1.5 Million Settlement

Benjamin Montemayor had been protesting on Hollywood Boulevard for several hours on June 2, 2020, when at least 50 police officers descended upon his group and began firing munitions at the crowd, according to his civil rights lawsuit filed in Los Angeles federal court.

May 17, 2024

Westlake’s Oldest Gay Bar Set to be Demolished

Opened in the early 1960s, the Silver Platter has long been known as a safe space for immigrant gay and transgender communities in Westlake. The building dates back to the 1920s.

May 17, 2024

What To Eat This Weekend Around L.A.: Salvadoran Fried Chicken Sandwiches, 48-Hour Pho, and Tacos Placeros

Plus, a new Enrique Olvera-approved monthly "mercadito" in D.T.L.A., a new arepa spot with patacon burgers that use fried plaintains for buns, and more in this week's roundup.

May 17, 2024

The 13 Best Tacos In Boyle Heights

Boyle Heights is arguably the city’s most important local taco galaxy in the larger taco universe that is Los Angeles. Remember, this is Boyle Heights! It's not East L.A., and it is most definitely not just some vague place known as “the Eastside.”

May 16, 2024

Here Are All the Restaurants (and the One Taquería In the Entire Country That Got a Star) On Michelin’s First Ever Mexico Guide

Europe's Michelin Guide recognized both Baja Californias, Quintana Roo, Mexico City, Oaxaca, and Nuevo Léon. Most of the usual nice restaurants got stars, but there were some questionable omissions. Also, in a country teeming with life-changing street food, only one taquería in the entire country was awarded "1 star."

May 15, 2024
See all posts