Skip to Content
Crime

Know Your Rights: LAPD Limits Officers From Searching For More Serious Crimes During a Minor Traffic Stop

On Tuesday, the Los Angeles Police Commission adopted a new policy limiting “pretextual stops.”

Pretextual stops—when police stop a driver for a minor traffic infraction to search for a potentially more serious crime—are technically legal but have been historically known to disproportionately impact Black and Brown communities. Police argue that traffic stops are fundamental to public safety.

According to recent data provided by William Briggs, the president of the Police Commission, last year, Newton Division LAPD officers in South LA stopped more than 27,000 people. Ninety-seven percent of those stopped were Black or Latino. During the same time period, in the department's South Bureau, more than 62,000 people were stopped, 95 percent were Black or Latino. Firearms were recovered in less than 5 percent of those stops.

“The current policy harms our Black and Brown communities. The current policy does not stop crime,” Briggs said on Tuesday.

In 2019, an L.A. Times report and Inspector General investigation similarly found that in South L.A., the LAPD’s Metropolitan Division disproportionately targeted Black and Brown drivers even though they were less likely to have contraband on them.

Under the new policy, officers must now state their reasons for stopping a driver on body-worn video camera. The policy was approved unanimously by the Los Angeles Police Commission—the civilian oversight body of the LAPD—and will go into effect immediately, despite concerns from both activists and the union who represents rank-and-file officers.

Union officials believes the policy will hinder officers' ability to investigate crimes. Activists aren’t necessarily pleased either. They argue that the new policy is too vague and believe that Black and Brown people will continue to be disproportionately targeted. “While claiming to restrict or limit these stops, the policy in fact spells out how officers can continue the same abusive behavior under a new guise,” a coalition of activists wrote in a group letter sent to the commission before the policy was approved. 

William Gude, a well-known critic of the LAPD who goes by Film The Police LA on social media, agrees that the new policy doesn’t go far enough to hold officers accountable. Yesterday on Twitter, Gude wrote, “Prediction: no officer will ever get a sustained complaint for violating pretextual stop rules, as there are major exemptions.”

On Wednesday, Gude told L.A. TACO that the new policy is “essentially meaningless.” But he still thinks it will have an impact on the pretextual stops that he regularly documents in Hollywood, where he lives. “I think being required to state the 'reason' for the search will lead to fewer searches.” Gude also believes that the new policy might decrease the number of “consensual” searches (when a driver voluntarily gives police permission to search their vehicle). “I truly think there are a substantial number of LAPD [officers] that don't understand what constitutes probable cause. Now they'll have to learn.”

Under the new policy, LAPD officers are only permitted to conduct pretextual stops when there’s a violation that “significantly interferes with public safety.” An officer must have “articulable information regarding a serious crime” before making a stop. Officers who break policy will first have to undergo training and will face more serious consequences for additional violations.

The policy does not define what type of information is needed to justify a pretextual stop or the amount of information needed. It does however make it clear that the decision cannot be based “on a mere hunch or on generalized characteristics such as a person’s race, gender, age, homeless circumstance, or presence in a high-crime location.”

All in all, the policy is a bit wonky and leaves a lot of discretion up to the officers making the stop in the first place. Under the new policy, when deciding to make a stop, officers are expected to use their “training, experience and expertise.”

What’s the worst that could happen?

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from L.A. TACO

Tens of Thousands of Angelenos Flock to L.A.’s Flower District for a Valentine’s Day Flower Free-For-All

Tens of thousands made their way to the city's wholesale flower capital, jamming the streets and sidewalks with countless flowers and people. L.A. TACO'S contributing photographer Kemal Cilengir was there to capture it all, including street vendors getting fined and the dystopian-like flower free-for-all being had by lovestruck customers and hustling vendors eager to offload their prized plants.

February 14, 2025

This Weekend: A New Bar-Setting Indian Restaurant, Duck Laab Pizza, and a Filipino Breakfast Diner Pop-Up

Have a three-day weekend full of chai cheesecake, black garlic cocktails, egg pie, and famous flour tortillas.

February 14, 2025

Self-Defense Against ICE: Community Groups In L.A. Are Uniting to Protect Themselves

More than 50 organizations have joined the call to join this coalition, making it one of Southern California's largest immigrant rights coalitions. The group aims to extend from the San Fernando Valley to the U.S./Mexico border. The coalition is organizing training sessions to prepare its members for community tactics to defend their neighbors from ICE raids and deportations. Their first mass protest is taking place on Monday.

February 13, 2025

Tacos Before Vatos: 13 Tacos In L.A. That Will Make You Forget About Him

For L.A. TACO, love is always in the air, and it smells like charcoal burning on a sunny day under carne asada and tortillas hot off the comal, with vibrant salsas, caramelized onions, and thick guacamole. Forget him, and spend time with things that matter in life: tacos, forever. 

February 13, 2025

Unmatched Hustle: Immigrant from Michoacán’s Tierra Caliente Creates Innovative Tortillería on Wheels…In Bakersfield

Many come and buy pounds and pounds to share with their family members as soon as they taste a warm “taco de sal,” a tortilla sprinkled simply with salt and rolled up like a thin flauta. It’s common to eat tacos de sal while waiting in line at a tortillería in Mexico, but not so much in the U.S. 

February 12, 2025
See all posts